Republican members of the House Armed Services Committee called on the U.S. Army to release the full results of a survey conducted to discover the reasons for the Army’s poor recruiting numbers in 2022 in a letter Wednesday.
The Army selectively disclosed results from the survey to show that the Army’s social justice policies and the COVID-19 vaccine mandate did not cause the service to fall 25% below its recruiting target for fiscal year 2022, Republican Reps. Jim Banks of Indiana and Mike Waltz of Florida alleged in the letter addressed to Army Secretary Christine Wormuth and provided to the Daily Caller News Foundation.
Service leaders claimed “wokeness” did not feature heavily in survey responses, but the Army has concealed most of the data and methodology of the study.
“We share the goal of recruiting and retaining our nation’s best and brightest for military service,” the lawmakers wrote. “In the interest of transparency, we call on the Army to publicly release its entire data set, instead of cherry-picking data to fit a narrative.”
As Army recruiting appeared to slow in the spring and summer of 2022, the service questioned a sample of 2,400 Americans between the ages of 16 and 28 to find out why young people were choosing options besides serving in the military.
According to the Army, which provided an overview of the survey results to The Associated Press, young people cited safety concerns and the stress of Army life as inhibitors to enlisting. They also said they didn’t want to steal time away from pursuing other careers.
Prospective recruits “just don’t see the Army as something that’s relevant,” Maj. Gen. Alex Fink, head of Army marketing, told the AP. “They see us as revered, but not relevant, in their lives.”
Although all branches of the armed services struggled with recruiting, the Army suffered the worst deficit relative to its goals, coming 15,000 recruits short of the 60,000 target.
One-fifth of survey respondents feared they would be “putting my life on hold” by joining, officials told the AP. Very few respondents — about 5% — referenced “wokeness” as a barrier to enlisting, officials told the AP. More concerning were reports of discrimination and harrassment against women and minority groups — roughly 13% of responses — as well as an overall loss of trust in the military.
The survey data is a tool to “assuage the concerns that some may have, whether influencers or members of Congress, about wokeness or the vaccine mandate — which is now rescinded — and show they are not, by any means, primary drivers of the recruiting challenges we’re experiencing,” Wormuth told the AP.
Licensing laws prevented the Army from releasing the full study conducted via a private contractor, officials told the AP.
However, interviews with former servicemembers conducted by the DCNF show that the vaccine mandate may affect people’s willingness to join a service that apparently discounted the religious convictions of servicemembers. In addition, experts say the Army’s targeted recruiting pool in 2022 already discounted or overlooked its traditional recruiting base.
“Wokeness at the [Department of Defense] has harmed recruitment, retention and morale, wasted service members’ time and taxpayer’s dollars and undermined the apolitical character of the military which is a major threat to democracy and the American way of life,” Banks said in a statement to the DCNF.
The Army did not immediately respond to the DCNF’s request for comment.
Waltz, Banks Call for Transparency on the U.S. Army’s Historic Recruitment Crisis (Press Release, 23 FEB 23)
On Wednesday, Chairman of the U.S. House Armed Services Subcommittee on Readiness Mike Waltz (FL-6) and Chairman of the U.S. House Armed Services Subcommittee on Military Personnel Jim Banks (IN-3) sent a letter to U.S. Secretary of the Army Christine Wormuth to express concerns over the historic recruitment crisis facing the U.S. Army today and to call for public release of important recruiting and retaining survey data.
“Having spent my career as an Army officer and green beret, I am very concerned with the Army’s ability to recruit and retain our nation’s best and brightest for military service,” said Waltz. “Unfortunately, we continue to receive analysis of cherry-picked data that is not giving us the full picture of why the U.S. Army is seeing historically low recruitment and retention rates. That is why Rep. Banks and I are calling for transparency and the public release of the Army’s entire data set concerning military recruitment. Right now, it should be the shared goal of Congress, our military leaders, and the Biden Administration to get to the bottom of this crisis so we can ensure our military is ready for any threat our nation faces.”
“Wokeness at the DoD has harmed recruitment, retention and morale, wasted service members’ time and taxpayer’s dollars, and undermined the apolitical character of the military which is a major threat to democracy and the American way of life,” said Banks. “I’ll ensure the Military Personnel Subcommittee prioritizes rooting out wokeness.”
You can read the full letter below:
Dear Secretary Wormuth:
The U.S. Army is in the midst of a historic recruiting crisis. In FY22, the Army fell 15,000 soldiers, or 25 percent, short of its 60,000-person recruitment goal.
The Army predicts FY23 will be worse, estimating its end strength will have a further shortfall of 20,000 soldiers. In anticipation of another poor recruiting year, the Army asked for their end strength to be cut by 33,000 active-duty soldiers from FY22 to FY23.
In light of this crisis, we write to you in response to reporting that states the Army conducted surveys of approximately 2,400 respondents aged 16 to 28 over a span of 4 months last spring and summer to discern why it is failing to meet its recruiting goals.
Notably, the Army declined to publicly release the survey’s entire data set and methodology, choosing instead to discuss its “general findings” with the Associated Press, which published an unverified, secondhand description of the survey’s findings.
Based on this unreleased data, the Army’s head of marketing, Major General Alex Fink, determined that young Americans “just don’t see the Army as something that’s relevant, they see us as revered, but not relevant, in their lives.”
General Fink went on to say that “woke” DOD policies were cited as an issue by between 4 and 5 percent of respondents nationwide, and that very few respondents say they are deterred from enlisting due to “woke” DOD policies and concerns about discrimination against women and minorities were seen as a bigger issue.
This purported data stands in stark contrast to publicly available polling data on military recruiting:
• A November 2022 poll conducted by the Ronald Reagan Institute found a sharp decline in the trust and confidence in the U.S. military, with 70 percent saying they had “a great deal” of trust in 2018, dropping to 48 percent in 2022. The most frequently cited reason for decreased trust was the “military becoming overly politicized.” Also found at the top of the list was “the performance and competence of presidents as the Commander in Chief, and “so-called ‘woke’ practices undermining military effectiveness.”
• A recent poll conducted by the Heritage Foundation found that 68 percent of active-duty military surveyed said they witnessed politicization in the military, and 65 percent of active duty are concerned with growing politicization of the military. The most selected areas of concern were “an overemphasis on diversity, equity, and inclusion programs; requirement for the military to pay for abortion related travel; reduction of fitness standards to promote equity.”
Further, the Heritage poll found that 68 percent of active-duty military personnel stated politicization of the military would impact their decision to encourage their children to join. This is particularly concerning, given the role that military families play in recruiting.
As the Chairmen of the House Armed Services Committee’s Readiness and Military Personnel Subcommittees, we share the goal of recruiting and retaining our nation’s best and brightest for military service.
In the AP article, you stated that the survey data is a tool to “assuage the concerns that some may have, whether influencers or members of Congress, about wokeness or the vaccine mandate – which is now rescinded – and show they are not, by any means, primary drivers of the recruiting challenges we’re experiencing.”
In the interest of transparency, we call on the Army to publicly release its entire data set, instead of cherry-picking data to fit a narrative. This issue is critical to our national security, and of great importance to the American people.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter. https://apnews.com/article/afghanistan-politics-military-and-defense-race-ethnicity-6548adcb0fee590f3427771d1e1eeea7?utm_source=homepage&utm_medium=TopNews&utm_campaign=position_07  Beacon Research, “US National Survey Of Defense Attitudes On Behalf of the Ronald Reagan Foundation – Final Topline Results,” Ronald Reagan Foundation, November 9-17, 2022, https://www.reaganfoundation.org/media/359964/rndf-survey-2022-topline.pdf (accessed February 6, 2023).  https://www.heritage.org/defense/report/poll-nearly-seven-10-active-service-members-have-witnessed-politicization-us