Forrest Marrion, PhD, a retired Air Force officer, VMI grad and military historian who has written many articles on STARRS, here writes an article about a Kentucky minister who, in 1824, warned about Islam, their end goal of getting 72 virgins when they die and why some non-Muslims are attracted to the religion (as some are today). Back then, the religion was called “Mahometanism” and Muslims where called “Mahometans” or “Mussulmans”.
An 18th-19th Century Presbyterian Minister’s View of Mahometanism
James Blythe (1765-1842) was a lifelong Presbyterian minister and educator. In 1824 Blythe addressed the Synod of Kentucky at its opening on the “Present State and Duty of the Church.”
By Forrest Marion
What is Mahometanism but a flattering appeal to some of the worst passions of our nature? Is any Mussulman taught to curb his ambition, to love his enemy, or to subjugate the evil propensities of his heart? So deeply does sense imbue the whole of this system, that the heaven of Mahomet is nothing better than a brothel. Now, when it is remembered what we are by nature—that from infancy to old age we are a mass of sensuality; who would wonder that there are so many Mahometans?
Two centuries ago many of the assessments of false religions around the world provided by Christians—and not only by ministers—were more honest than they are today. Our forefathers knew nothing of what is commonly called politically correct speech. They were in a Christian society and saw their country as part of Christendom. And rightly so. Moreover, they feared God, not men—which must always bring a snare (Proverbs 29:25).
James Blythe (1765-1842) was a lifelong Presbyterian minister and educator, a 1788 graduate of Hampden Sidney [later, Sydney] College in Virginia, where he committed himself to preparing for the ministry. After completing his training in North Carolina, Blythe moved to Kentucky not long before it attained statehood (1792). He preached his first sermon at the Lexington area’s Pisgah Church in 1791, beginning a forty-year ministry to Pisgah and another Lexington area church.
The setting for Indian attacks, some of them British-inspired, scalpings and other atrocities—carried out by both sides—made Kentucky a wild place in the late 1700s and early 1800s. Theologically it was just as untamed, marked by everything from widespread atheism (infidelity) to oases of orthodoxy, questionable revivals and associated behaviors to ministers’ defections and bitter church splits (including Kentucky Baptists).[1]
In addition to preaching, Blythe taught chemistry for many years and served for more than a decade as acting president of the Presbyterians’ Transylvania University in Lexington. In 1816 he was elected the Moderator of the Presbyterian Church’s General Assembly.
In 1824 Blythe addressed the Synod of Kentucky at its opening on the Present State and Duty of the Church. He was not one to mince words. He could be theologically and ecclesiastically combative when the circumstances required. His text was “Isaiah XL. 3, 4, 5.,” which reads:
The voice of him that crieth in the wilderness, Prepare ye the way of the Lord, make straight in the desert a highway for our God. Every valley shall be exalted, and every mountain and hill shall be made low: and the crooked shall be made straight, and the rough places plain: and the glory of the Lord shall be revealed, and all flesh shall see it together: for the mouth of the Lord hath spoken it.[2]
Beginning his discourse, Blythe declared, “There can be no question but the future glory of the church is one main object of the prophecy, and particularly the glory of the church as it respects its extent.”
Speaking broadly, a few lines later: “Few things have been so much the subject of conversation in our world, as the church of Christ. Upon a review of the last 2,000 years, would we not be disposed to say, the church has been the only permanent, unchangeable interest which those 2,000 years have presented to the mind of man?”
The minister moved across the centuries addressing the various and shifting philosophies of men in contrast to the unchanging, saving truths of the Bible and Christianity. He noted that the death of one system of error in the world typically gives birth to another:
. . . What is Mahometanism but a flattering appeal to some of the worst passions of our nature?
Is any Mussulman taught to curb his ambition, to love his enemy, or to subjugate the evil propensities of his heart?
So deeply does sense imbue the whole of this system, that the heaven of Mahomet is nothing better than a brothel.
Now, when it is remembered what we are by nature—that from infancy to old age we are a mass of sensuality; who would wonder that there are so many Mahometans?
Have we not reason to be astonished that this religion of sense, has not desolated the whole human family?
Nor need we be at all surprised, in our intercourse with men of certain principles, to find them rather leaning to the Alcoran [the Koran] than the Bible.
This is no more than sailing with the current—embracing that which is pleasing to a corrupt taste, and rejecting that which calls upon us to reform and amend our ways.
The above remarks apply with all their force to every system of Pagan religion upon earth.
We defy their admirers to find any thing like purity of heart and of life in one of them.
There sits enthroned the DEMON OF LUST. He is surrounded with a priesthood as loathsome as himself, and the millions who bow in homage at his feet, are driven on to self-sacrifice and to death, under the hope that the extinguishment of the lamp of life, which burns too feebly for their raging desires, will, beyond the grave, be immediately so re-enkindled, that all the fancies of their polluted imaginations will then be realized.
Such, if we mistake not, is the true philosophy of Mahometanism and Paganism.
Dr. Blythe had much more to say beyond his remarks on Mahometanism but at this point called his friends to turn their minds to “the immaculate purity of the Bible” and to remember its holy demands.
A fellow pastor and Blythe’s lifelong friend, William Hill, wrote: “He had great tenacity of purpose, and was always candid, and sometimes a little abrupt, in the expression of his opinions….He commanded great respect wherever he was known, and filled an important place in society with marked dignity and usefulness.”[3]
Forrest L. Marion is a ruling elder in the First Presbyterian Church (PCA), Crossville, Tennessee.
[1] Barry Waugh, “James Blythe, 1765-1842,” Presbyterians of the Past, Nov. 1, 2025.
[2] James Blythe, A Discourse on the Present State and Duty of the Church; Delivered at the Opening of the Synod of Kentucky [Oct. 1824] (Lexington, Ky., 1824), quote. Subsequent quotes [emphasis in original] taken from this discourse, unless noted otherwise.
[3] William B. Sprague, Annals of the American Pulpit . . . (New York, 1858), III:591-95, quote.
_
Dr. Forrest L. Marion is a retired Air Force colonel, former helicopter pilot, and military historian whose career spans three decades of uniformed service and 25 years as a civilian historian for the Department of the Air Force. He specializes in Air Force history, special operations, combat search and rescue, military advisory operations, and the development of the U.S. Space Force.

Leave a Comment